In Big Brother 4, she was the ninth evicted from the house, and the sixth member of the jury. Her ex-boyfriend Robert Roman was also in the house, as part of the X-Factor twist.
Erika was one of the twenty former houseguests given the chance to compete in Big Brother All-Stars, and was selected by the public to enter the house. Erika ultimately finished as the runner-up, receiving only Marcellas' vote to win the game.
Erika, along with Paul Abrahamian of Big Brother 18 holds the record for most nominations in a season (All Stars) by a member of the Final 2 with 6.
Erika is one of six players to make the final four at least twice:
Janelle Pierzina (3rd place in Big Brother 6 and Big Brother All-Stars), Will Kirby (Winner of Big Brother 2 and 4th in All-Stars), Jordan Lloyd (Winner of Big Brother 11 and 4th in Big Brother 13), Dan Gheesling (Winner of Big Brother 10 and Runner-up in Big Brother 14), and Tim Dormer (Winner of Big Brother Australia 10 and 3rd in Big Brother Canada 4).