Jeff played a quiet game overall, with his former Amazing Race partner, Jackie Ibarra. However, in Week 3, he soon became a target to Austin Matelson when he began having a flirtatious relationship with Liz Nolan and figuring out Liz could be a twin and her other twin Julia Nolan was playing as Liz. This resulted in Austin convincing his alliance members that Jeff was a danger to their game. Vanessa Rousso and Austin then staged a fight with Jeff to make him public enemy number one so that they had reason to send him out the door.
After being thrown onto the block by Vanessa, he was evicted by a vote of 7-4. He placed 15th.
Jeff admits he's finally ready to transition from douchey guy to gentleman-someday soon. He says he only dates attractive women but knows that he needs to start focusing on what they have to offer besides their outer shells. He is an aggressive guy who negotiates business deals on a daily basis, so he knows that he has the competitive edge it takes to win the game of Big Brother. He is a sore loser who will do anything to ensure that he wins every competition. Most recently, he competed on the 26th season of The Amazing Race with a blind date partner he met at the starting line.
Jeff was in the house for all three takeover twists, including him and Jackie being the two mystery houseguests. After he left, the twists stopped.
During the beginning of the season, a scandal occurred between him and Julia Nolan where they were sleeping in bed together during the day. It appeared he was masturbating under the covers, and later seemed to rub something on the back of her shirt. This caused controversy, many fans outraging and wanting to get Jeff evicted.