Johnny quickly formed a bond with Kevin and Naeha on the initial stages of the game. When the votes were publicly revealed during the Instant Eviction, his loyalty to Naeha put a target on his back, which landed him a position in the minority alliances of the house. He was spared the next week, when Brittnee won HOH. He won the Power of Veto that week to save Kevin and successfully follow through with Brittnee's plan to backdoor Graig. When Bruno won HOH the next week, he was targeted for eviction alongside his ally, Sarah. In the POV competition that week, he was betrayed by all of his allies, including Kevin, and was subsequently eliminated. In an effort to save himself, he campaigned for votes and tried to exploit Sarah's game despite staying on the block. He was unsuccessful and was the fifth houseguest evicted from the house. As a part of the first five evicted houseguests, he was given the opportunity to return but was once again unsuccessful in the challenge and finished in 13th place.
Johnny Colatruglio is a 26-year-old IT project manager from Winnipeg, Manitoba. He is a self-proclaimed superfan of the show, even naming his dog Veto. He believes he will get along well with his fellow HouseGuests, though claims he will clash with "dumb blondes" and messy people. He is the only openly gay HouseGuest this season.