Throughout his stay in the BBCAN Grand, Mitch was able to manipulate all sides of the house, playing a floater game similar to Cassandra. He lied in the middle, waiting for the two power alliances of Kelsey, Jared and Raul against Maddy, Ramsey, and Dallas to go against each other and eventually knock each other out. He was considered a favourite to win the game until the Wildcard twist sent Kelsey Faith back into the game to expose his strategy. He was considered too dangerous and became the first member of the Jury on Day 42.
In the end Mitch voted for the brothersNick and Phil to win the game. He described their game as being an extremely lucky one.