Sabrina started out her game very strongly, where she created the First Five alliance which dominated the first four weeks of the game, and had strong influence in who was nominated and evicted. However, during Week 5, Sabrina's game began to fall apart. With Canada as Head of Household, the nation nominated both her and fellow First Five member and ally, Andrew Gordon. The house chose to evict Andrew over Sabrina, as he was seen as a stronger player. Canada's reign as Head of Household caused Sabrina to go into a downward spiral, where both her strategic and social games became extremely weak, along with already being a weak physical competitor.
Starting on Day 43, Sabrina was always one of the two initial nominees, but was never voted out due to virtually every remaining player viewed her as an excellent person to sit with in the Final 2, as she was seen as an easy person to beat. She finally won a Head of Household at the Final 4. During the Final Head of Household competition, Sabrina failed to win any part of the competition. Eventual Final Head of Household Jon Pardy chose to take Sabrina over huge jury threat Neda Kalantar. Sabrina lost to Jon in a 6-1 vote, only gaining the vote from close friend Rachelle Diamond.
Sabrina became notable online for her emotional breakdowns and outbursts, especially one meltdown where, after Rachelle stated that Head of Household Adel explained that he nominated them as he thought it would make for good TV, she angrily exclaimed "Does everyone want good fucking TV? Is that what they want?! I'm gonna fucking show you good fucking TV!".